Never mind the quality


I had a meeting recently in a particularly lovely space. The office was in one of Sydney’s old warehouses and it felt fabulous. There were high ceilings, plenty of windows drawing in oodles of light and lots of solid wood (columns, beams, floors). The stylish chairs and sofas were covered in one of my favourite materials, wool, all in soft greys and reds. Lighting was discreet. It all screamed quality.

On my way home, I kept thinking what it was that had struck me so strongly, although maybe it’s clear from my description. And yet I’ve been in spaces that have looked similar and I haven’t felt the same thing. Why? Were the wooden floorboards narrower and of a cheaper wood?  Was the furniture more generic, the fabrics less appealing?

It made me wonder what exactly quality is. How do we recognise it? Or rather, how do we manage so often to overlook it? The answer, perhaps, is in that well-worn phrase: never mind the quality, feel the width. It was said of tailors in London who would push cheaper fabric to the customer to optimise their profit. (And it was the name of a creaky old TV sitcom about two East End tailors, one Jewish, the other Irish – I’m sure you can imagine the ‘humour’.)

Quality is not the same as style or taste and doesn’t necessarily have anything to do with money, either. Sure, that office space was expensively designed but someone else might have looked at the bare brick walls and thought them rather basic and in need of a good plastering. Others might prefer floral fabrics to felted-wool. To me, the quality was in the solidity of the materials, the lack of fakeness, the way things spoke for themselves. It’s that ‘honesty’ thing that Modernism always called for, where nothing pretends to be anything else. Something of quality gives you more than you expect. It makes you feel better. Quality gives quality to life.

the quality of honest structure

And yet we still fall for tricks, or at least for what is dished out to us.

Recently I was looking for a new jacket. It was surprisingly hard to find one that hadn’t been tweaked with manmade fibres or given a jazzy lining or some other little feature. I felt they were all designed to take my eye off the fact that they weren’t very good quality. It took me ages to find something plain and simple and made of good fabric. It wasn’t any more expensive than the others so it wasn’t even a case of ‘you get what you pay for’.

Fifteen years ago I was given a Giorgio Armani tee shirt. There was nothing but a tiny label sewn inside the neck, no big logo on the chest. I had always thought that ‘designer’ clothes were a bit of a swizz but that tee shirt taught me a great deal about quality. It’s something of a marvel. Despite being worn umpteen times over so many years, the fabric remains soft and strong and looks like new if I can be bothered to iron it. It’s kept its shape and has never pilled. In the meantime, I’ve gone through any number of cheap tee shirts which lost shape, whose fabric wore out, and whose stitching came apart. Old Giorgio just keeps going on. Why? Because it’s beautifully made from high quality fabric. Lesson learned (or at least noted, because I still find myself unable to splurge that much on a new tee shirt.)

the quality of generous space

The idea of quality is in everything.

  • The quality of space – when a door or a passageway is wider than usual or a room has a higher ceiling than usual, the quality is generosity. Mean spaces at the top of stairs or just inside entrance doors give you a niggly feeling and usually say much about the quality of the rest of a building.
  • The quality of good conversation – someone who listens to you and remarks and questions what you say, versus someone who only uses your words as a springboard for their own thoughts and observations. Don’t you feel uplifted after a ‘quality’ conversation with one person, rather than drained by empty-calorie chatter with another?
  • The quality of writing – good story-telling shows time has been spent over it, the element of crafting. Good writing is apparent in everything from high literature to potboilers, and it’s very apparent when it’s not there. Don’t you feel let down by lazy writing, and having wasted your time over a badly done novel?

    the quality of good writing

  • Leather upholstery in a car used to be a sign of a quality motor. Today it’s usually the cheapest cars that have fabric seats although the leather in many cars, including in upmarket brands, is often fake pleather. That’s not for any moral reason, trying to cut down the number of cows needed so that their methane doesn’t affect global warming, but more about replicating the real effect cheaply. It’s simply the fake Rolex going mainstream and becoming acceptable, and it’s everywhere.
  • The quality of restaurant food that has been cooked with care rather than cooked quickly and put on a plate (or a wooden board/ slate/ boot, etc) with lots of tiny dabs of this and that to make it appear interesting. Never mind the quality if there’s so much of it, too.

    the quality of simple food, beautifully presented

  • The quality of a building which does things that surprise and delight you, rather than just exactly what you expect. I’m thinking of Le Corbusier’s apartments in Marseille, with so many thoughtful touches that make life easier and more pleasurable (steps to sit on, stairs to cling to, knobs to hang pans on). I’m also thinking of the rash of new houses rising in so many Australia towns which have lots of odd shapes and materials to take your eye off the fact they’re cheaply built and poorly planned. The same budget spent on something simpler that is tailored to real life demands would surely be better. We’ve fallen for open-plan when that’s often code for cost-cutting – fewer walls and no doors might be cheaper to build but it makes for more ambient noise and a less liveable environment. So maybe quality is a room with a door.

    the quality of simple architecture

  • The quality of good design – like the Braun calculator that looked beautiful (it inspired the first iPhone) and did everything it was meant to in a pleasing way – nice buttons, clear display, good to hold. It’s what drew people to Apple, after all, because things looked beautiful and worked seamlessly most of the time. I remember changing a headlamp globe on my old Saab and how simple and easy it was. I did the same on a Ford and cut my hand to ribbons. The idea of good design extending beyond what is visible is a clear sign of quality. I admit some of it does tend to add cost. But not always. And that’s the thing that baffles me. When something is popular then it becomes cheaper to manufacture. IKEA used to do it, using proper wood instead of plastic veneers, but even that has changed.

    the quality of thoughtful design

  • The emoji – pick a symbol that sums up a mood or a comment. Quick and easy. But drawn by someone else and therefore de-personalised. Are actual words going to become out-dated?

The list goes on. Don’t you think it’s time for a revival in the quality of quality?

So what does quality mean to you?

the quality of order

 

 

 

 

Categories: Design, WritingTags: , , , , , , ,

12 comments

  1. I’ll take quality over quantity in just about everything. With space, I think there’s some sort of magic that happens when good design gets together with the right environment and good materials. A real ‘whole is greater than the sum of the parts’ thing. As for writing, I won’t (can’t) spend time with the bad stuff. And when it’s good, you barely notice it’s there! That is how great stories get told. Nice post!

    • Thanks, Mel. You’re so right with the ‘whole thing’ – it’s when you walk into a space and think: this is lovely, and so is this, oh and so is this, and it all comes together in a glorious, nurturing feeling of quality. And the same with reading a book, when you realise you’re in good hands. I’m getting better at simply putting down books I’m not enjoying so my quality-meter must be operational…

  2. The quality of a great blog post, like this one. Well worth reading, sir. Loved it.

  3. Hi Colin just thought I would let you know that the next big exhibition at SCVA opening March finishing September is ‘Superstructures – the new architecture 1960-1990”. David and I were just talking about you when your blog came through,,,.. fancy some Prouve, Rogers, Foster, Buckminster Fuller, Grimshaw, Hopkins. Going to be a big one!

  4. A wonderful observation, Colin. Too often monetary value or faddy styling are placed above real quality, whereas we would benefit from a wide revival in attention to detail and in a greater care in design / manufacture

  5. A really interesting post, Colin.
    What I wonder is whether there is a universal standard for quality.
    You use the word ‘honesty’. Is that the sign of quality, that the item is honestly what it is? With no shortcuts, no masking, no substitutions. It is a big subject.
    I think I chose our house for it’s quality and honesty. I loved the front door with the stained glass above, it’s Gothic arch in the hallway and the fact that it has a fireplace in every single room. It felt like the house it was really meant to be. And I am grateful to live where every single day.

    • It’s such a flexible word that gets blurred with taste – I might view gold taps as awful, someone might see them as a sign of quality. But regardless of that, if the gold taps are well made and work beautifully then they might be said to be of high quality. Whether one needs gold in a bathroom is another matter… I think the idea of integrity is involved – that a design is thought-through, that a material is solid (even if it’s concrete) and not pretending to be something else, and that it has the consistency of style, which you mention your house has. Often it is when you open a cupboard or turn a chair over and see that the part that no one will generally see is still beautifully finished – that screams quality to me, and it’s something seldom seen as we are so often given the look or veneer of integrity but integrity itself. But you’ve touched on another notion – the quality of being fit-for-purpose, that lynchpin of good design, and to feel that when you walk into a building is a remarkable thing.

  6. Rather bizarrely I thought of a few things: the political debate in this country at the moment, my father’s mind and pilling on jumpers! My father had a very elegant mind and a high quality intelligence. He gave himself time to think and was always interesting to listen to because he came at things from a broad range of reference and study. i disagreed with his politics but I miss that elegance of mind. The quality of debate in say the referendum about the EEC was so abysmal and the quality of leadership on the subject now is abject. Finally pilling on jumpers. Whether they are expensive or inexpensive it seems to be the same and I don’t remember that from my childhood at all. Incidentally apologies for not commenting before I seem to have lost notifications for a few blogs I follow and yours is definitely one I do not want to miss!

    • Oh yes! The quality of a well-informed mind capable of communicating in ways that inspire – brilliant. Quite something to live up to, too, if it’s someone in your family. And on the pilling front, I think school jumpers were the worst, or maybe it was just the many times I sat through a maths class being more interested in picking off the tiny balls of fluff that’s cemented the experience in my mind. (Welcome back, by the way – WordPress does seem to do this from time to time, losing notifications.)

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

kirilson photography

the stories behind the pictures, and vice versa

Not-so-modern girl

a girl living in the wrong century who loves reading, writing and all things book-ish

Anthony Hillin

Training, Facilitation and Policy development

Just Merveilleux?

Life at № 42

Notes from the U.K.

Exploring the spidery corners of a culture and the weird stuff that tourist brochures ignore.

MOVIE-WARDEN

Motion-picture Reviews

SAVING OUR TREES - Marrickville municipality

Community Tree Watch - working to protect healthy public trees in Marrickville municipality from inappropriate removal

MOVIE MUSIC UK

Film Score Reviews by Jonathan Broxton since 1997

A life in books

Book news, reviews and recommendations

150 great things about the Underground

An unofficial birthday salute to a public transport titan

Man Genius of OZ Lit. Reviews

Not here to make friends

A new life in Lille

Tales of a Brit who moved to Hauts-de-France

Mistakes & Adventures

What I've always wanted

eme de moca

Architecture, experiences, design, moca...

Expedictionary

Literary Geography

UNSW Built Environment's Blog

Information from students and staff at Built Environment at the University of New South Wales, Sydney Australia.

joe moran's words

on the everyday, the banal and other important matters

a little bit of Ingrid

the little things, the little moments...they aren't little!

French Country

My life in France is not what I expected.

Wee Notions

Notes on a napkin

ABOUT SOMETHING AROUND

There is no time to be bored in a world as beautiful as this.

artdecocollector.wordpress.com/

Documenting Great Britain's surviving art deco & early modernist architecture

The Secret Bookseller

The Secret Bookseller is a blog written by an Independent Bookshop Manager about running a bookshop, publishing, customers and bookselling

agentofstyle

Lifestyle

Rebecca Renner

Journalist | Essayist | Fiction Writer

Heritage Calling

A Historic England Blog

A Sense of Place

Ronnie Hughes

Jerry Coleby-Williams

Sustainable Gardening in our Continually Surprising Climate

Mathieu Proctor

Urban Planning + Design

The Australian Interestingness

Aesthetics and cultural trends in late modernity

Savidge Reads

The Chronicles of a Book Addict

Barnabas Calder

Raw Concrete: the Beauty of Brutalism

Ticket to Adventures

Travel blog from around the world, near and far.

Kelly Schuknecht

Writer, Marketing Specialist, Remote Work Advocate

%d bloggers like this: